The logo for mr. auto insurance shows a man in a suit driving a red car.
INSURING fort myers for over 36 years

We Specialize in Saving You Money

Get a Quote
Because everyone deserves a co-pilot in the ride of life.

Experience the Difference with Mr. Auto Insurance

Unparalleled customer care, a family presence, and support for clients from all walks of life.

Drive with assurance – our car insurance options provide dependable protection and peace of mind on all your travels.

Protect your home with our reliable insurance options, providing you and your family with peace of mind.

Protect your hobbies and activities, as well as your own safety and that of others on the road and waterways.

Discover specialized business insurance solutions designed to protect your assets and promote long-term prosperity.

Serving fort myers, florida, and the surrounding area

Experience. Choices. Affordability.

For 36 years, our family-owned business at Mr. Auto Insurance has been rooted in a simple mission: to provide affordable insurance solutions to everyone, no matter their background. As a small, family-run operation, we pride ourselves on personal service and a commitment to ensuring that every member of our community can access the coverage they need.


Whether you're insuring your RV, motorcycle, truck, watercraft, home, or business, our commitment is to your protection and peace of mind. As independent agents, we connect you with a broad range of insurance solutions from various companies, giving you with the freedom to choose coverage that fits your budget.

More About Us

Free Insurance Quotes Available!

Unlock your personalized, no-obligation quote now and discover the value of security at no cost.

Get a Quote
An aerial view of a road surrounded by houses and trees.

What Our Clients Say

Jackie Goldman

Tammy and Matt are awesome! Extremely helpful, polite and professional.
Great people great help

carlos houston

Great people great help

Anne Willett

Tammy is the BEST! Went above and beyond.

Miguel Corea

Great service

Marie Williams

Great service I’ve worked with Tammy over the years great service friendly & helpful!

Danielle Cominos

I can’t even begin to explain the level of attention and customer service provided by Dave and his office. Just through a few phone calls, ALL of which the owner himself, always was readily available to take my call. I really got the feeling like he treated me the way you would treat a family member. He saved me over $100 a month and got me better coverage than any other company could’ve in all of the 25 years I’ve been driving. I recommend him and his company to anyone looking for a great price and even more amazing Customer Service.

CARI BROWN

Great service, professional & courteous and 6+ years they never let me down finding affordable auto coverage. Thank you!

Erin Ryan

Excellent experience everytime 👏 Tammy is amazing. I've been with this company for years, fast- efficient and easy. ***Update2023...Tammy is STILL THE 👌BEST, Excellent customer service excellent customer care every time with this company

chiquita Daniels

They take great care of their costomers

Noel Umberger

They are the best in prices and Tammy is amazing at customer service. She made everything so pain and hassle free. It was an absolute pleasure in having her as my agent. I will recommend this insurance company to all my friends and family because of her service.

Victor Sapen

Great people

Benjamin Haywood

Down to earth customer service representative awesome ...... A great understanding of your insurance needs

Tiffany Coleman

They treat you right and very understanding! 👌

Anastashya Andujar

Dave works with multiple insurance companies, 100% recommend this company to my family and friends.

Rick Major

My name is Angela and I have been with Mr. Auto Insurance, off and on for years. Several vehicles insured by them. They have been nothing but professional, understanding of all my questions and needs, helping me through a hard situation, that they took the time to fix. Tammy Robinson, thank you from the bottom of my heart for your time, effort in helping me, as well as Dave, all Employees. You all are amazing. I highly recommend Mr. Auto to anyone, who is looking for great rates on auto Insurance, as well as a great company to deal with. Thanks again, Angela

Kelli Wildman

Friendly, outgoing staff that really help you

April nicole

Best insurance company cheap

Carrie Leverrett

Good customer service. I see the same staff for 10 yrs

Dan Kelly

David is very awesome there at the insurance company everybody is nice

Fran Underwood

Fast and courteous

Mickey D

The staff were very kind and helpful.

Tammy

Service is great.

brion howard sr

Great rates. Very informative

Cayla Helfrich

Tammy was great! She was very nice on the phone and made sure to find the best deal for me. I Definitely recommended Mr. Auto for your insurance needs.

Juanita Jimenez

Recommended 100% The people there take their time and don’t treat you like a number , but as a friend. Been there for a while and Not planning on going any where else. Thank you Dave for your time and Service.

Lannette Dunn

Sooo nice people there

Kelli Wildman

Tammy me helped me cut my insurance payment in half ❤

Jackie Weinrich

Koop is unbelievably helpful. This is my second time getting a car from him. My first car never had any issues. I fell on some hard times but koop was able to help me out and get me into a 2016 chevy malibu! I highly recommend any and everyone coming to him and his team when you need a vehicle! Thank you guys sooooooo much!

Judy Johnson

I love the people who work here

Marilyn May

Their very professional and they came up with a very reasonable priced insurance for me.

Britt

This place is great I had them in my younger years n just went back still same owner great insurance quotes friendly agents who care

Daniel Forte Landscaping

(Translated by Google) Great (Original) Buenisimo

Jackie Goldman

Tammy and Matt are awesome! Extremely helpful, polite and professional.

carlos houston

Great people great help
Share by: